All posts

Broken Link Checker Plugin Alternatives for WordPress (That Won't Slow Your Site)

Broken Link Checker plugin alternatives for WordPress: cloud plugins, light local plugins, crawlers and hosted monitors that keep load off your server.

Published 10 min read

The Broken Link Checker plugin by WPMU DEV is one of the most installed tools in WordPress, with more than 500,000 active installations, and for good reason. It finds dead links in your posts, pages, comments and custom fields, and lets you fix them without leaving the dashboard. But it's also one of the plugins people most often go looking to replace, usually because of server load, a host that discourages it, or because they need checks beyond WordPress.

This guide covers the main Broken Link Checker plugin alternatives: what each one does well and what it gives up. It also helps you figure out whether you need a replacement at all, or just a different setup of the plugin you already have.

Why people look for an alternative

It's worth being fair here. The plugin works, and many site owners have used it happily for years. The common reasons people move on are these:

Server load from local checking. A link checker running on your own server makes an outbound HTTP request for every link it checks. It also stores what it finds in your database and does this work in background jobs that compete with your visitors for the same PHP workers and database. On a small site you won't notice. On a site with thousands of posts and tens of thousands of links, especially on shared hosting, local scanning can noticeably slow the admin and sometimes the front end.

Hosts that discourage it. Some managed WordPress hosts steer customers away from plugin-based link checkers. WP Engine's disallowed plugins page, for example, recommends external tools for broken link checks because, in its words, "As they are not plugins these will not have a negative effect on your site's performance."

False positives and noise. Any link checker that requests pages from a server gets blocked sometimes. Sites behind bot protection or rate limits may answer with 403 or 429 even though the page works fine in a browser. Reviewers on the plugin's page have complained about false positives, which is a problem every checker has to manage, not just this one.

It only sees WordPress. The plugin checks content stored in WordPress. If your important links also live in a docs site on another platform, a Shopify store, landing pages built elsewhere, or email templates, a WordPress plugin can't watch them.

Before you switch: try the cloud engine

Since version 2.0, Broken Link Checker has offered two engines. The local engine runs on your server as it always has. The cloud engine runs the scans on WPMU DEV's servers, which the plugin describes as giving "better performance and reduced server load". It needs a free WPMU DEV Hub account. If server load is your only complaint, switching engines may solve it without changing tools.

If you need something else (no account, checks outside WordPress, alerts in Slack, or just fewer plugins), read on.

What to look for in a replacement

Whatever you pick, judge it on these points:

  • Where do the checks run? On your server (load on your hosting) or on someone else's (no load, but usually an account).
  • What does it check? Only WordPress content, or any URL you give it, including other platforms and outbound links.
  • How often does it check? One-time scans, a manual schedule, or automatic recurring checks.
  • How does it tell you? A dashboard you have to remember to open, or email and Slack alerts that come to you.
  • Can you fix links in place? Plugins can edit the post for you. External tools tell you what's broken, and you fix it in WordPress yourself.
  • What happens at scale? Link limits, page limits, and what happens when you exceed them.

The alternatives, by type

Broken Link Checker by AIOSEO is the closest like-for-like swap. It stays inside wp-admin and lets you edit or remove broken links from its dashboard, but the scanning runs on AIOSEO's servers instead of yours. It checks internal and external links, images and video embeds.

  • Good: no scanning load on your host. You keep the in-dashboard fixing workflow, and get weekly and monthly email reports of what broke.
  • Trade-offs: needs an AIOSEO account. The free plan covers 250 internal links a month, so most real sites will need a paid plan. It only covers WordPress content.
  • Best for: WordPress-only sites that want the plugin experience without the server load.

2. A lightweight local plugin

If you'd rather keep everything on your own server with no third-party account, newer plugins are built around staying light. LinkTender, for example, checks links in small, time-limited background batches with throttled requests per domain, and doesn't need an account or API key.

  • Good: free, no account, no data leaves your server, fixes in the dashboard.
  • Trade-offs: still uses your server's resources, just more carefully. It also only sees WordPress content and depends on WP-Cron running reliably.
  • Best for: privacy-conscious or self-hosted sites with a moderate number of links.

3. A desktop crawler (Screaming Frog)

Screaming Frog SEO Spider crawls your site from your own computer, the same way a search engine would, and reports every broken link along with the pages that contain it. It's the standard tool for technical SEO audits.

  • Good: no plugin and no load beyond a normal crawl. Very detailed, and it checks outbound links, images and redirects too. It works on any platform, not just WordPress.
  • Trade-offs: it's a one-time audit unless you buy a licence and keep a computer running for scheduled crawls. The free version is limited to 500 URLs, and there are no alerts.
  • Best for: periodic deep audits, migrations and redesigns.

4. Google Search Console (free)

Search Console's Page indexing report lists URLs on your site that Googlebot found returning 404, including old URLs that other sites still link to.

  • Good: free, no plugin, no load, and it shows the 404s Google is actually hitting.
  • Trade-offs: it doesn't check your outbound links at all, updates on Google's schedule rather than yours, and doesn't always point you to the page that contains the bad link.
  • Best for: a free baseline that every site should have alongside any other tool.

If you manage many WordPress sites, ManageWP's Link Monitor runs automatic daily link checks (up to 10,000 links per site, per ManageWP) and sends alerts. You can edit, unlink or ignore broken links from the ManageWP dashboard.

  • Good: built for agencies already using ManageWP, with fixing from one place.
  • Trade-offs: tied to the ManageWP ecosystem and to WordPress sites.
  • Best for: agencies that already manage their clients' WordPress sites in ManageWP.

A hosted monitor works the other way round from a plugin. It doesn't live inside WordPress at all. You give it the URLs that matter, and it checks them from its own servers on a schedule and alerts you when one fails.

Brokenlink is a hosted monitor. You import your site from its sitemap.xml or paste a list of URLs, such as your key pages, affiliate links or important outbound links. Every link is rechecked every 24 hours. When one fails (4xx, 5xx, a timeout or a DNS failure), you get an email or Slack alert with the exact URL and error code. It also sends daily, weekly or monthly status reports and keeps 30 days of history per link.

  • Good: zero load on your server and no plugin to install or update. It works for any URL on any platform, so WordPress, Shopify, docs sites and email links can sit in one place. Alerts come to you by email or Slack, and projects and labels keep multiple sites or clients organised.
  • Trade-offs: it doesn't edit your WordPress posts. It tells you what broke, and you fix it in the editor. Sitemap import brings in your pages. Outbound links you want watched, such as affiliate links, are added as their own list of URLs. It's a paid service after the 14-day free trial (no card required), starting at $9/month for 1,000 links (pricing).
  • Best for: sites where links earn money, teams that live in Slack, and anyone with links spread across more than one platform.

Comparison at a glance

Where checks runCovers non-WordPress linksAutomatic recurring checksAlertsFix inside WordPressAccount needed
Broken Link Checker (local engine)Your serverNoYesEmail, dashboardYesNo
Broken Link Checker (cloud engine)WPMU DEV serversNoYesEmail, dashboardYesFree WPMU DEV Hub
Broken Link Checker by AIOSEOAIOSEO serversNoYesWeekly and monthly email reports, dashboardYesAIOSEO account
Lightweight local plugin (e.g. LinkTender)Your server, throttledNoYesDashboardYesNo
Screaming FrogYour computerYesPaid licence, computer onNoNoLicence beyond 500 URLs
Google Search ConsoleGoogleYour own URLs onlyGoogle's crawl scheduleOccasional emailNoGoogle account
ManageWP Link MonitorManageWPNoDailyYesYes, from ManageWPManageWP
Hosted monitor (Brokenlink)Brokenlink serversYesEvery 24 hoursEmail, SlackNoYes, 14-day trial

Feature details for third-party tools come from their own pages at the time of writing. Check them before you decide, because plans change.

Which one should you choose?

  • You like the plugin but your server doesn't: switch Broken Link Checker to its cloud engine, or move to AIOSEO's cloud-based plugin.
  • You want no third-party account: a lightweight local plugin, plus Search Console.
  • You're on a host that discourages link-checking plugins: an external tool. Screaming Frog for audits, a hosted monitor for ongoing checks.
  • Your links make money, or live outside WordPress: a hosted monitor that alerts you by email or Slack, with an occasional Screaming Frog crawl for deep audits.
  • You manage many client sites: ManageWP if you already use it. Otherwise a hosted monitor with one project per client and scheduled reports.

Many sites end up with two layers: something that watches the important links every day and alerts you, and a full crawl a few times a year or after big changes. How Often Should You Check for Broken Links? covers how to set that rhythm.

How to switch without losing anything

If you're replacing the plugin, do it in this order so you don't end up with a gap:

  1. Export or note what the plugin currently reports. Fix or write down the broken links it has already found, so you start clean. (How to Find and Fix Broken Links covers the fixing part.)
  2. Set up the replacement and run a first check. For a hosted monitor, import your sitemap and add your important outbound links. If you need a list of every affiliate link first, this guide includes a script that builds one from your sitemap. While you're at it, make sure your sitemap itself is clean (here's how).
  3. Compare results. Expect some differences. Each tool handles redirects, bot walls and timeouts a little differently. Confirm a sample of broken links in a browser.
  4. Deactivate and delete the old plugin. Deleting through WordPress lets the plugin run its own uninstall cleanup, which may or may not remove the tables it created. Check your database afterward if keeping it lean matters to you.
  5. Set up alerts to reach the person who fixes links. A replacement nobody reads is worse than the plugin you removed. See How to Monitor Broken Links Automatically for alert routing that people actually act on.

The short version

  • Broken Link Checker is a capable, very popular plugin. People replace it mainly for server load, host restrictions, false positives, or because they need to watch links outside WordPress.
  • If load is the only problem, try its cloud engine before switching.
  • For the plugin experience without load, use a cloud plugin (AIOSEO). For no account, use a lightweight local plugin.
  • For no plugin at all, combine Search Console with Screaming Frog audits and a hosted monitor for daily checks.
  • Brokenlink rechecks every link every 24 hours from its own servers and alerts you by email or Slack. Nothing runs on your WordPress install, and you can try it free for 14 days with no card.